Interesting post on the CarLocate blog today.
I read the
referenced article in the post. To summarize, areas that have banned cell phone use while driving are not seeing a decline in reported accidents. If cell phones use causes accidents (as also reported in research findings) then why are accident rates not declining in areas with bans?
Anyone have any thoughts to those questions? There's the obvious answer that people haven't actually stopped texting or talking while they drive, but the article suggests that other studies have shown the ban has been partially successful on reducing cell phone use while driving. Perhaps then the individuals who were responsible enough to obey the ban are not the ones who needed their cell phones taken away?
I feel like the information presented in the article is only painting half a picture. For example, has there been a reduction in serious accidents since the cell phone ban for the area? The article is lumping all accidents in one pile, without any break down on the severity of the accidents. If cell phone use slows reaction time then I would image that an accident related to following too close to someone would be much worse if the user was distracted by a cell phone because the reaction time would be slower and the vehicle would be moving faster when the collision occurred.
Here's what I want to see: Don't compare accident data as one lump sum. If there are studies that can tell how many accidents were caused by cell phones then break down all accidents that way (cell phones, weather, drunk driving, night driving, fog, etc) in terms of what caused the accident. Do that for both before and after cell phone ban studies or using a "control group" of a non-banned area like the article discussed in the blog post did. I'm curious to see what type of accident will go up if cell phone as a reason goes down. Is there something new that has replaced the distraction of the cell phone? Is the number of cell phone related accidents still high despite the ban and despite the reduction in cell phone use? I feel that is important information that is left out to really complete the study presented.
Sadly it could very well be that a percentage of people simply do not devote the attention to driving that they should and if one source of distraction is removed, they will simply find something else to occupy their eyes and attention while they drive.
Just my thoughts anyway...